Movies based on video games are stinkers. Generally, most of them piss gamers off (Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within had virtually nothing to do with the game Final Fantasy), some drawing in peanuts in terms of gross, all ruthlessly mauled down by critics and reviewers, and a number of them were absolute cinematic catastrophes. (The House of the Dead, Street Fighter)
Here are the numbers to prove the point:
| Movie Title | Rotten Tomatoes rating (out of 100%) | IMDb rating(out of 10) | US Gross(in USD)
|
|---|
| Tomb Raider | 17% | 5.2 | $131,144,183
|
|---|
| Tomb Raider: The Cradle of Life | 24% | 5.2 | $65,653,758
|
|---|
| Mortal Kombat | 26% | 5.0 | $70,433,227
|
|---|
| Mortal Kombat: Annihilation | 5% | 3.1 | $35,927,406
|
|---|
| Street Fighter | 27% | 3.1 | $33,423,000
|
|---|
| Resident Evil | 35% | 6.2 | $39,532,308
|
|---|
| Resident Evil: Apocalypse | 22% | 5.8 | $47,758,000
|
|---|
| Super Mario Bros. | 8% | 3.5 | $20,844,907
|
|---|
| Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within | 45% | 6.5 | $32,131,830
|
|---|
| The House of the Dead | 4% | 2.3 | $10,199,354
|
|---|
| Pokemon: The First Movie | 8% | 3.4 | $85,744,662
|
|---|
| Wing Commander | 7% | 3.6 | $11,578,022
|
|---|
| Double Dragon | - | 3.1 | $2,341,309
|
|---|
*Rotten Tomatoes reflects the view of critics/movie reviewers, IMDb reflects general moviegoers’ opinion on the movie.
Based on data, Tomb Raider made the most respected profit (having a production budget of $90,000,000 and raking in $274,500,000 in terms of worldwide gross) despite it being loathed by reviewers. Its secret?
1. Angelina Jolie. Take away Angelina Jolie, and you take away Millions of dollars with it.
2. Bath scenes, push up pads, tight and skimpy outfits.
3. It is hard to piss off fans of the video game. There are too little interesting characters, personalities, storyline, unique minions and villains to mess around with. As long as it features Lara Croft kicking butt with double handguns it would do the job.
This is further reinforced by the fact that although the first episode sucked (I will not go into that), the second episode still attracted a number of “willing sufferers”, myself included (the sequel grossed $65,653,758 in the US). We all knew what we were going to get all along.
Anyway, the title of this article is not “How to Make a Movie based on Video Games that sells well” but “How to Make a Great Movie based on Video Games”.
So far, not one single video-game-turned-movie was loved by fans of the game, equally fancied by non-game-fans, acclaimed by movie critics and reviewers, and also proved to be a successful hit financially.
Here is a general guideline, mostly lessons learnt from the above failures, you break one of these, you break the movie, and the movie will end up in the long list of “video game movies that stunk”.
1. Stay faithful to the original.
Final Fantasy was one of the better made movies(of the above), but to the regular fans, it was much more rewarding and entertaining to watch
Yuna at a
cosplay session than to watch the movie.
In contrast, Mortal Kombat reeks bad. It has bad plot, bad acting, bad dialogue. Its winning move was a simple one: stuff in all the characters that you could think of in the video game, and make them perform tricks just like the video game, and there you are, a decent profit, (70 million US gross on a 20 million budget), and some very happy and entertained game fans that are shouting “this movie sucksssss!” while whispering “guilty pleasure” in their hearts.
2. Choose the director wisely
Paul W.S. Anderson directed and screwed up Mortal Kombat and Resident Evil. Recently, he screwed up Alien vs Predator. Need I say more?
(Alien vs Predator is based on the video game that is based on the comic that is based on the two movie franchise, Aliens and Predator, so it is not strictly a “video game movie”)
3. Have a brilliant script and coherent plot
Easier said than done. If you chose a video game from an action based genre (FPS, brawlers, fighting games), chances are the story in the game is weak and characters not very well developed (or not developed at all in the case of hitman and doom). Make sure the screenwriter do his homework!
In the case of a video game that already has a well known and well liked world, storyline and characters that fans can easily relate to, chances are non-fans will also be hooked with the movie that is based on the video game. In this case, it is a no-brainer that you base the script on the already established game world and characters, or even better, base your movie 100% on the game. Lord of the Rings did not kick ass by introducing purple orcs, half-naked avians and harpers.
This point leads to my multi-million idea:
MAKE A MOVIE BASED ON AN ADVENTURE GAME
The following illustration is a comparison between the recent box-office hit Pirates of the Carribean and the classic adventure game Monkey Island(great potential to be made into a movie).
Protagonist
Will Turner
vs
Guybrush Treepwood
Verdict: Guybrush Threepwood puts Will Turner, the boyband member lookalike to shame with his humor, wit and creative use of insults (and whatever he lay his hands on- pretzels, balloons, plastic chickens).
Love Interest
Elizabeth Swann
vs
Elaine Marley
Verdict: A governer’s daughter against the governer herself as the love interest? Elaine Marley packs a mixture of charm and authority and shines in this contest. Elizabeth Swann may have better luck in a beauty contest or screaming contest.
Antagonist
Barbossa
vs
LeChuck
Verdict: Both are ghost pirates. Both are captains of their respective ghost ships and command a horde of terror. I call this a draw.
Trusty sidekick
Jack Sparrow
vs
nobody
Verdict: Jack Sparrow ain’t the regular trusty sidekick, his pinch of evil stands out amidst his kindness; moment of brilliance shines in his clumsiness. Guybrush Threepwood does not have a trusty sidekick nor any regular strong allies, Pirates of the Carribean really got it right this time with Jack Sparrow.
Final score: Pirates of the Carribean 1 – 2 Monkey Island Movie
If a movie has the potential to beat Pirates of the Carribean, you know it is definitely worth making it.
Besides the main characters, there are also a handful of interesting side characters in Monkey Island - Murray the talking skull, Stan the salesman that can’t stop talking, Hernan Toothrot the hermit that does not wear pants. All these colorful characters, along with the misty, mysterious setting of islands – Dinky Island, Booty Island, Melee Island, Monkey Island, stitch ‘em all up with the intense rivalry of Guybrush vs LeChuck and romance of Guybrush vs Elaine, it will surely be a masterpiece!
My conclusion: to make really great video game movie, take a game that already has a strong script and make an adaptation. Games from either the adventure or RPG genre have such good stories that put many movie scriptwriters to shame. Giving Lara Croft a bad pass with her father does not help, neither does giving the doom marine dude a name and the ability to talk help.
The trend of cashing in on hype and turning action games into movies is still continuing, check out the list of upcoming movies based on video games:
1.
Alone in the Dark
2.
Doom
3.
Blood Rayne
4.
Dungeon Siege
5.
Metroid
6.
Far Cry
The long list of video games turned movies(and turned stinky) is expanding, stay tuned!
Source:
1.
Rotten Tomatoes
2.
IMDb
3.
The Numbers
4.
Coming Soon